Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Shaq As Orlando Magic General Manager? Don't Bet On It

FIRE WOODSON!!!


Look, the offense is much worse even though the players are mostly the same. The defense appears to be much improved but that's largely because Tyson is one of the best in the game.

It's no wonder the one change that coincided with the the Knicks drop from mediocre to bad. Mike Woodson. He is a terrible coach in every way. Well-coached teams know exactly what to do against the Knicks because they're so predictable. Check the Knicks' wins this season. Pretty much a who's who of the worst coaches in the NBA.

Look, it even says so here:

http://basketball.realgm.com/wiretap/218746/Rivals_Believe_Knicks_Defense_Too_Predictable

Comment 37 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Posting and Toasting

Tuesday Egyptian Mastigures

May 2012 by Seth - 41 comments

Saturday Beaked Cape Tortoises

May 2012 by Seth - 21 comments

Thursday African Fat-Tailed Geckos

May 2012 by Seth - 115 comments

Comments

Display:

too bad

that all the fools clamoring for d’antoni to be fired believe woodson is a perfect fit and obvious choice.

/// aighttho.com \\\/// twitter.com/aighttho \\\

by stingy d on Feb 3, 2012 2:41 PM EST reply actions  

Yeah I agree

I don’t know how you can have two opposing philosophies and have the players successfully execute both.

by ubd on Feb 3, 2012 2:54 PM EST reply actions  

I don't know much about Woodson

But I know the Hawks didn’t do shit with him as coach and they have had their core guys for more than a few years now…. and they are a solid bunch. They made some noise last year, but this is all post-Woodson.

I am not impressed at all. Amare and Melo look no different than they did last year and though I wasn’t expecting drastic changes from them, I did expect improvement with the addition of Tyson Chandler. But I don’t remember such chaotic run-away D the Knicks showcase when other team set picks. It’s comically bad too.

And maybe one reason for the offensive struggles could be frustration with the defense and having the players essentially deal with 2 head coaches??

Maybe Pringles was right to balk at this kind of thing when he was in Phoenix cus it hasn’t inspired much confidence in New York. Even though our defense is improved as whole, I kinda attribute that more to the players on the floor than the assignments.

"Madison Square Garden is the ultimate basketball stage. That's where I belong. That's where I live. That's the home of the New York Knicks." - Amar'e Stoudemire

by Chris Child's Fist on Feb 3, 2012 4:32 PM EST reply actions  

So the D is improved and your solution

is to fire Woodson? So you all want this idiot D’antoni to have his brother take over? great let’s go back to giving up 105 pts a game. The offensive struggles are due to D’antoni not having the players to execute his offense. If they fire Woodson, D’antoni better be right out the door behind him.

by mrluck35 on Feb 3, 2012 11:06 PM EST reply actions  

D is better because of Tyson Chandler

It’s pretty clearly not the schemes. The O is significantly worse than last year despite similar players. They’re not executing because Woodson is distracting the players with his stupid ideas, and D’Antoni was undermined and doesn’t like being there. Hiring Woodson was a terrible idea.

by mindfeck on Feb 3, 2012 11:28 PM EST up reply actions  

Woodson....

Was nowhere near the huddle during a few of the breaks…something’s not right here…

by Mdotpain on Feb 3, 2012 11:38 PM EST reply actions  

that's because Woodson is full of crap and only those idiots who want MDA fired believe he is great

His Hawks were the most inconsistent bunch of guys I ever watched and so weird. The guy is only here because MDA got tired of the criticism and was basically forced to hire him. Tyson and other players are the reason for better defense.

by RASHADI on Feb 4, 2012 2:49 AM EST up reply actions  

THANK YOU!!!!!

FINALLY somebody who sees Woodson for what he is. A decent defensive mind, and mediocre at best head coach. Firing D’Antoni will fix nothing folks!!!! Start figuring that out. How bout something else to consider, and Van Gundy said this during the Heat game last week: Maybe the Knicks just arent that good. Ding Ding Ding!!! Wow, nobody probably ever thought of that!! This team right now does not have chemistry, does not have any semblence of a point guard, and has no bench. Much as I hate to, we have to wait for Davis, or I think better would be ship Douglas’ ass outa town and whatever else and grab Sessions( and it still stands, I will carry him on ma back!!!) Then also pains me to say but they now HAVE TO sign JR Smith. I mean idk where else your gonna find bench scoring at this point in the season and being capped out. So at this point patience is probably the only real answer.

by Nickel06 on Feb 4, 2012 8:33 AM EST up reply actions  

I still don't understand who thinks so highly of Woodson

Dude gets fired and suddenly Hawks beat Orlando and they did easily. All they had to do was switch Horfort to PF position and put a bunch of back ups on Howard and let him dominate, get to free throw line, etc, but keep his team mates cold. It worked and ATlanta beat the magic. Woodson had the most inconsistent team when he coached them and I don’t ever remember him being mentioned as a good defensive coach. I am still somewhat lost as to why he is here for defense. Defense has improved because of Tyson, Jorts, Shump and others players have bought into it, They could do this without woodson but MDA got tired of the media and criticism so he added him to his staff just to say “fuck you” to the press and critics.

by RASHADI on Feb 4, 2012 2:47 AM EST reply actions   1 recs

This is a hilarious fanpost

so the D is better all because of Chandler? so Woodson gets no credit. The Knicks suck right now, but D’antoni gets a lifetime pass, the D is improved under Woodson so let’s fire him cuz he sucks. Whi is drawing up the defensive rotations Chandler? come on. D’antoni needs to be fired before Woodson goes. There is no way anybody can justify to me how you can keep D’antoni. I’m sick of all the excuses about new players, the lockout, whatever your excuse is. This team is 8-15, the same record as the Nets. So it’s Carmelo Anthony’s fault the O sucks and Woodson gets no credit for the improved D, and D’antoni gets a lifetime pass from any blame.

by mrluck35 on Feb 4, 2012 6:23 AM EST reply actions  

you're more hilarious along with your Woodson

Why isn’t he in Atlanta if he is so good? Why was he fired again? Yes, you’re right, he gets no credit because teams will play better defense when there are better defenders, duh. Let’s not pretend like Woodson is a Pat Riley or the current Bulls coach. If the Bulls coach or someone else was available, Woodson wouldn’t even be here. Your boy Jennings was clowning Woodson defense and he knows it as they played the Hawks in the playoffs. You can hate Mike all you want to but Woodson won’t coach this team better. If he was so good, His Atrlanta team would have made it past Orlando but they couldn’t hang because Al Horfort kept getting in foul trouble.

That’s your Mike Woodson.

by RASHADI on Feb 5, 2012 1:40 AM EST up reply actions  

No D'Antoni gets all the blame

However, Woodson doesn’t get the credit for the defense at all. Unless you are arguing that his plan was to have Tyson and Jeffries each guard three people every trip down the floor, because that is what is happening. Tyson Chandler is busting his ass on defense, and Jeffries is working pretty hard as well. By the way you don’t draw up defensive rotations, I love it when you guys talk coach. SMH

by Robert Curre on Feb 6, 2012 5:32 PM EST up reply actions  

This blog post and most of these posts following

are a joke. Go look up a stat: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_Woodson – his coaching record each yr. He made a small market, mediocre talent team into a consistent playoff team – they got better every year. Not contender, but a solid team built on TEAM D. Agreed I am not sure about his O, but that is not his role here. I know we Knick fans no longer can recognize good coaching or D, so even when it may be on the roster we blame Toney Douglas. Right. Notice we dont use MDs system, and there has been at least one coach to do ok without a PG (something about a Triangle offense)…it’s like MD doesn’t even know how to try sensible adaptations to his ideas given the roster at hand. He’s always a player away.

MD is terrible on every level at this point. We dont use his one strength and he has no other real good coaching qualities other than being high profile. He’s never developed a player of note (Amare benefited from his O and one of the greatest PGs ever , he didn’t develop new aspects to his game…like D, go figure). And now we can watch TD be inconsistent, Fields regress, Shumpert losing his great D (just as Landry did last year – who would be a great defender if we played some team D). Hell one of MDs best players ever was David Lee – a guy who had all those skills before MD came along, aside from the increased numbers that come in that O.

Our first problem really is Dolan. Then any hires / moves that have his fingerprints on them (save bring in Walsh). MD, Isaiah, Melo trade, losing Walsh…oh well. This group to me is the most embarrassing NYK group we’ve ever played mostly because of a lack of cohesion, effort and attitude – and worse their inability to see THAT. All you have to do is look at the best teams around (NBA – Bulls, Den…hell NFL look at NYG!! Not just for success, but attitude, work ethic in general).

by ChaChing on Feb 4, 2012 12:07 PM EST reply actions  

lol@Woodson

You forgot to mention that more talent was added and that’s why they became better. His team reached its zenith and remained that way. They could barely beat the Bucks, and they now beat Orlando after Woodson was fired. Great Coach huh?

by RASHADI on Feb 5, 2012 1:42 AM EST up reply actions  

Did you just say that David Lee played defense before D'Antoni got to the Knicks?

David Lee didn’t even play defense at Florida and Billy Donovan still considers him the worst defensive player he’s ever coached. You do Realize the Balkman’s career high in college came when he was being guarded by David Lee right?

by Robert Curre on Feb 6, 2012 5:35 PM EST up reply actions  

Gentlemen, I am a displaced Knick fan living in Arizona . . .

Therefore, I have had the rare “treat” of watching just about every Suns game during the Dantoni era, many of them in person. Not because I was a Suns fan, it was simply the only basketball on tv to watch.

This is my 8th year of Dantoni, not many can make this claim. I knew from the moment he got the Knicks job that we were totally screwed.

Everyone here in Phoenix knows that Steve Nash actually coached that team, Nash was essentially a player/coach.

That is rare these days, but Steve Nash’s talent is even rarer.

I have seen Nash draw up the final play on the clipboard during time outs, Nash is the person that got in the ear of players taking poor shots, Nash was the ball mover/facilitator and made mediocre talent shine.

One mediocre talent was Mike Dantoni. Steve Nash being the humble guy that he is, would give credit to Dantoni for everything. He sincerely liked Mike and wanted to help him any way he could.

The man did not coach the Suns, he merely orchestrated the substitutions and the time outs. He was more of a manager. Nash the head coach.

Now we see what Mikey D the manager looks like without his head coach Nash around.

This ugly experiment is called your New York Knicks.

Remember this is my 8th year of Dantoni ball, I know this man inside and out. He is not a coach, he is a manager.

by TheKnicksAreBack on Feb 4, 2012 1:28 PM EST reply actions  

You have seen Nash draw up the final play

Then guess what you probably have seen Jordan, Kobe, Larry Bird, and Magic Johnson do it as well. When coaches trust their players they actually allow them to have input. If a coach draws up a play and the player thinks it will not work, then it is a sign a=of maturity from the player and the coach to come up with something different. Hell in football quarterbacks do it all the damn time its called an audible. Eli Manning changes 65 percent of the plays that are sent him during an average game. Is he coaching the team? No, does he have the freedom as the guy on the floor who sees the defense and knows what he can do and what he can’t, yes. You guys really need to get beyond the stereotypes of D’Antoni and realize that 99% of the stuff you guys complain about happens with other coaches as well.

by Robert Curre on Feb 6, 2012 5:40 PM EST up reply actions  

TKAB - With you...obviously!

Gets Ws (sells tickets) no matter how flawed the team but always loses come playoffs. Not fundamentally sound & efficient basketball. Then add Melo who brings the system to a halt – a player who only helps a team win a ring if EVERYONE else around him has the right attitude & plan despite him. That requires a smart coach who knows his players (Doc Rivers, George Karl – though even he couldn’t get Melo right). Not one who has NO chance at making them better. We have great potential in Fields, Shumpert, TD, Jorts. If we had any motion on O & played D they would all being having good years. Just like Fields until the Melo trade. And then from just the revenue perspective, if we don’t run his ticket-selling offense…???

I’d love to see what Woodson could do, who has brought that to ATL. He has an awesome resume playing for Bob Knight, coaching under Larry Brown on the Pistons championship and drafted by NYK. We might already have the players. They are definitely a hell of a lot better than the current record. In fairness to MD the current NYK situation is less his fault than Dolan’s. But he still is a huge problem and needs to go.

by ChaChing on Feb 4, 2012 1:58 PM EST reply actions  

206-286 record no thanks

Even our pathetic Knicks team under Pringles smoked him 3 out of 4 games. And Both Larry Brown’s and Woodson’s rings are tarnished by the fact that they inherited a championship contender. You do realize that Rick Carlisle took that Detroit team to the ECF the year before and probably wins it if Billups didn’t get hurt right?

by Robert Curre on Feb 6, 2012 5:43 PM EST up reply actions  

I just told this story on another thread . . .

I was lucky enough to have a courtside seat near the Suns bench when they we hosting the Knicks. Here is what I witnessed:

“From my courtside seat I watched Mikey D. draw up a last second play and he showed it to Nash first. Nash just shook his head "no." Then grabbed the eraser out of Mikey D’s hand like he was a ball boy.”

“Nash quickly drew something up, which I could not see unfortunately, and went over to the huddle and explained it to the team. I believe the result was a nice wide-open, top of key, three pointer that Nash swished.”

“I’ll tell ya, that Steve Nash can coach! There are a million other things I have seen over his 5 years in Phoenix, but do I really need more than that one story there to convince the Pro-toni’s out there?”

by TheKnicksAreBack on Feb 4, 2012 2:22 PM EST reply actions  

Check out the long, more detailed version I just wrote on

The “Rating and Debating: What does D’Antoni do with Toney Douglas?” thread

by TheKnicksAreBack on Feb 4, 2012 2:56 PM EST reply actions  

Regardless of the story...tho its funny and believable to a degree...

He does not instill any form of cohesion, discipline, maturity or confidence in his players, nor do anything but regress in terms of fundamentals and D. I could even ignore stats if we could look back and say “He really developed _______ to be an all-around better player” Not one player who got better at anything but PPG or in a very few cases FG%. Its a cute system but A) will never win a ring without D B) isn’t as tough a matchup for other teams as it was 10 years ago and C) we dont run it anymore. We need basic effort, attitude and fundamentally sound ball. We could run motion and the pick and roll / 2 man game on O and just go all focus on D and be a better team today than this embarrassing garbage. (BRING BACK JVG!!!)

by ChaChing on Feb 4, 2012 7:53 PM EST reply actions  

Even if you don't think D'Antoni is a great coach

You should realize that Woodson has brought a number of problems with him, and the defense is very predictable. Shumpert + Tyson Chandler would make any defense much better than what they had last year. Plus they play Jared Jeffries who is pretty much only defense. Woodson deserves no credit for that.

In terms of the Hawks becoming better while he was there, the talent increased finally. You can’t give Woodson credit for the Hawks and not give D’Antoni credit for the Suns, when the Suns were much more successful.

And that story about Steve Nash managing the team- I’m not surprised. It’s like with the Colts this year. And you know what, any coach would let Nash run a play for himself since he’s one of the best shooters ever. I haven’t liked what D’Antoni’s done, but at least he made some adjustments.

by mindfeck on Feb 5, 2012 9:11 AM EST reply actions   2 recs

The guys who come around here pining for MDA to be fired are so transparent. It's more predictable than our defense!

These guys come out swinging and act like everyone else gives Pringles a free pass for the Knicks record. That shit is what sells you guys out instantly. If you really paid attention to this site consistently, you would see (or should see) how we absolutely DON’T offer any free passes for ANYONE. Mike D’Antoni’s system has been so meticulously broken down, over analyzed, dissected, and run through the damn grinder that it isn’t even worth breaking down anymore. There are strengths and there are flaws.
But you guys think you can just sum it all up with one line and think you have the answer. Don’t be such fools.

You know what D’Antoni has gotten? It sure as shit hasn’t been a pass. He’s gotten patience. At least that’s what we are trying to give him. This is the NBA, kids. This isn’t NBA Live 2012 where you can just pick one guy and make him go off every game and then trade some bullshit to end up with an All-Star team. We’ve got one of the most dynamic scorers in the game, but even I can see that one guy can’t just bulldoze a defense ISO style and think you can win the game.

NBA Defenses will stop that shit after 2-3 tries if you keep doing the same damn thing every time. Our guys are starting to mesh and that shit takes time. It doesn’t have anything to do with the plays. It’s getting used to what each other guy can actually do. You look at a team like the Celtics and they know exactly how to execute their shit. They know where to be and they do exactly what they need to do, especially when the game is on the line. But look at our Knicks against them. Did nobody notice how willing Carmelo was to pass out of the double/triple teams?? He’s starting to get it! He dished to a ROOKIE in crunchtime, and then against to a 2nd year 2n-round draft pick. No, the wide open shots didn’t go in, but that is the first fucking step. Dude has started to trust his teammates. Now, it didn’t happen when Melo forced that final 3 over 2 guys, but that is another step we will take in time (hopefully). The ISOs were less because the Knicks are becoming more willing to let someone other than Melo and STAT handle the shots. You gotta make teams respect your teammates so you CAN go ISO every so often though.
D’Antoni is the head of this team. But you can’t fucking force chemistry. It has to happen in its own time. And of course there are extenuating circumstances that make it even more difficult this season. In Games, you need that W so you go with what you know and what works. There’s no time to hold hands with each other and learn on the fly. Practice is where you learn that shit. The Knicks struggles are the combination of everything bombarding them from all directions. The lack of a playmaking PG, the Win-Now mode, the shortened leash of the coach who is fighting for his job in a shortened season where teams are playing 4+ games a week every week, the new defensive coordinator he was forced to hire, the roster with so little flexibility because of past trades executed by OTHER PEOPLE. Man, this season isn’t about JUST the Coach. There is no one person to blame for anything here.

"Madison Square Garden is the ultimate basketball stage. That's where I belong. That's where I live. That's the home of the New York Knicks." - Amar'e Stoudemire

by Chris Child's Fist on Feb 5, 2012 10:54 AM EST reply actions   3 recs

Welp...guess I don't need to post about THAT in this thread now.

GJ CCF

I dream of Eddy Curry feeding me fish sticks.

Look at it Dave. Look at it.

by GAx on Feb 6, 2012 1:30 PM EST up reply actions  

I got kinda riled didn't I :-)

It was like… I saw Luis Scola’s face just laying there… all unprotected. And I just went for it! Nobody was lookin’!

Sometimes, the fist comes out.

"Madison Square Garden is the ultimate basketball stage. That's where I belong. That's where I live. That's the home of the New York Knicks." - Amar'e Stoudemire

by Chris Child's Fist on Feb 6, 2012 3:27 PM EST up reply actions  

TITLES WITH ALL CAPS

MAKE ME THINK THE POST WILL BE UBER RATIONAL!!!!!

GO CUSE, BLUE, AND EAGLES!

by tanman5 on Feb 6, 2012 1:14 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Posting and Toasting: Blogging the Knicks Robin Hood-Style Since 2007

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Ed-in-chief_small
Updated Knick Pride 2.0: Bocker Bench goes bonkers
Ed-in-chief_small
Knick Pride
Jorts6_small
Next Season's Roster and the Cap and the Tax

Recent FanPosts

Small
The Draft Workouts - What does Math Show Us?
Small
Tyson Chandler NOT on NBA All-Defensive team???
Small
If you were Lin's Agent, would you Pick the Knicks?
Small
American in Taiwan Jeremy & Woodson
Clydeuglysuit_small
Proposed Amare TRAID!
Ed-in-chief_small
Knick Pride 5.0: Spread the love
Ed-in-chief_small
Updated Knicks Pride 4.0: The funny and derpy!
Ed-in-chief_small
Updated Knick Pride 3.0: Eye candy for the ladies (Men, enter at your own risk)

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >